Contrast

Heart rate in a contrast session, read round by round

In a Contrast session, heart rate is drawn as one line across the whole session, coloured by round and shaded hot, cold and rest, with the highest and lowest points marked. It climbs through a hot bath, jumps on entering cold water from rest, then settles. Heat raises heart rate by moving blood to the skin, so a high reading in the heat is not exercise.

A contrast session has a shape you can see in the heart rate before you read a single label: slow climbs, sudden jumps, flat stretches. Each part of that shape has a known cause, and a couple of them are easy to misread.

Where the heart rate appears

On the watch, the first page during a session shows your current heart rate beside the round’s average. Turning the Digital Crown gives the round’s current, average, lowest and highest heart rate.

On the iPhone, each session’s page has a rounds list with every round’s average heart rate, its temperature and its length. With Contrast Pro, the session page adds a heart rate chart: one line across the whole session, coloured by what you were doing, over shaded bands for each hot round and cold round, with rest in grey. The session’s highest and lowest points are marked with their values, and the chart pinches to zoom.

Pro also adds a water temperature chart, time in each temperature band, and minutes in each heart rate zone. When a session has the right kind of rounds, a card called Your responses lists the three per-round measures described below, each with the minute it happened.

A hot bath: the slow climb

In hot water, heart rate rises steadily for as long as you stay in. Heat raises heart rate by moving blood to the skin, where it can shed heat.

How steep the climb is depends on the water. Heart rate is not a straight line with temperature. In one lab study of young men immersed for an hour, water at 32 °C and at 20 °C lowered heart rate by about 15% compared with sitting in air, while 14 °C raised it by about 5%. Hot water raises it steeply.

That climb can look like exercise on a chart. In a study of 19 adults, heart rate and blood pressure in a 93 °C sauna matched cycling at 60 to 100 watts, but the body uses far less oxygen in the heat than on a bike, so heart-rate formulas for calories fail there. Contrast shows the minutes and does not convert them.

A sauna round: often no line at all

Heart rate in a sauna needs the watch on your wrist, and Apple advises against wearing any Apple Watch except Ultra in a sauna, and against wearing Ultra above 55 °C (130 °F). A traditional sauna is usually hotter than that.

So in most sessions the sauna round is timed with the watch outside, and the chart shows the round’s shading with no line through it. Where there is a line, from an Ultra in a cooler sauna, humidity moves it a great deal: in a Finnish study at 80 °C, heart rate rose about 60% in dry air and about 130% once the air was made humid.

Into the cold from rest: the jump

Getting into cold water from rest produces a sharp spike in the first seconds, then a fall. That spike is the cold shock response. Contrast measures it as your highest 15-second heart rate in the first 45 seconds in the water, minus your median heart rate from 60 to 10 seconds before you got in.

Cold shock is rated established, because the lab studies measured it the same way. In one, eight healthy men did six 3-minute immersions at 15 °C over four days; their heart rate in the first 30 seconds of a 10 °C immersion fell from 128 to 109 beats a minute, and stayed lower for months.

The spike looks different straight after heat. Heart rate is already high when you step out of a hot bath or sauna, so there is less room for a jump. Contrast counts cold shock only for plunges in water of 20 °C or colder taken at least five minutes after any heat.

After the jump: the settle

After the spike, heart rate comes down from its peak. Contrast’s cold settle measure times that: the seconds from the highest 15-second heart rate in the first 45 seconds until heart rate is halfway down to where it sits between minutes 2 and 3, for plunges of three minutes or more.

Cold settle is rated borrowed, and the gap is the important part. The lab work found that the early response to cold water got shorter with repeated immersions. This particular half-way timing is Contrast’s own construction on top of those findings, not tested as a measure itself, and it is read only against your own earlier plunges in the same water band. It works after heat as well as from rest.

A third measure, heat strain, comes from the first hot round: your heart rate five minutes in, above that day’s resting heart rate. It is also borrowed, from exercise heat-acclimation research, where the effect is clearer than for passive heat.

The zones

The zone chart sorts the session’s minutes into five bands as fractions of the max heart rate set in the app: below 60%, 60 to 70%, 70 to 80%, 80 to 90%, and above 90%.

Those bands were built for exercise. In the heat, the heart works without the muscles asking for more oxygen, so time in a high zone during a bath describes the load on the heart and says nothing about fitness or calories. In the cold, the brief spike can land a few seconds in a high zone that reflects a reflex rather than effort.

Gaps, lag and what the line cannot show

Cold makes wrist heart rate patchy. Apple says that in the cold, blood flow through the skin of the wrist might be too low for the sensor to get a reading. Contrast leaves those gaps as gaps, and when it adds up time in a zone, each reading counts for at most 15 seconds, so one reading cannot stretch across a dropout.

Wrist heart rate also trails a sudden change by several seconds, which is why the cold shock window is 45 seconds where the lab studies used 30.

The line is an optical estimate from the wrist. It is not an electrocardiogram, it cannot show heart rhythm, and an unusual reading is a reason to talk to a doctor rather than something the app interprets. Check with a doctor before starting sauna or cold exposure, especially with a heart condition or high or low blood pressure.

Common questions

Why does my heart rate jump when I get into a cold plunge?

That jump is the cold shock response, part of the body's reflex to sudden cold. In a lab study it shrank after repeated immersions. Contrast measures it as the highest 15-second heart rate in your first 45 seconds in the water, minus your heart rate just before.

Why is my heart rate high in a hot bath if I am sitting still?

Heat raises heart rate by moving blood to the skin to shed heat. In one study, heart rate and blood pressure in a 93 °C sauna matched cycling at 60 to 100 W, but the body uses far less oxygen than in exercise, so Contrast does not convert it to calories.

What are the heart rate zones in a Contrast session?

Five zones as fractions of the max heart rate set in the app: below 60%, 60 to 70%, 70 to 80%, 80 to 90% and above 90%. The zones were built for exercise, so in the heat they describe how hard the heart is working, not fitness.

Why are there gaps in my heart rate during a plunge?

Apple says that in the cold, blood flow in the wrist can be too low for the sensor to get a reading. Contrast leaves gaps as gaps and caps how long any one reading can count for.

Sources