Resting heart rate: seasonal, noisy, and still worth watching
Contrast takes the median of your last 28 days of Apple Watch resting heart rate and compares it with the 28 before, and with the same weeks last year when there is a year of data. Changes under 2 bpm show as steady. Resting heart rate is seasonal and one person in five has a week that swings by 10 bpm, which is why the comparison is built this way.
Resting heart rate is the most quoted number on any wearable and one of the most misread. The design of this card is mostly a response to how noisy it actually is.
What the number is associated with
A meta-analysis of 46 studies covering about 1.25 million people found that each 10 bpm higher resting heart rate was associated with 9% higher all-cause mortality and 8% higher cardiovascular mortality.
That is a population-level association across a very large sample, and it is the reason anyone tracks the number at all. For most adults, 60 to 100 bpm is the normal range; very active people sit well below 60, and some are as low as 40.
What it is not is a personal score. A 10 bpm difference between two people says much less than a 10 bpm change in one person, and even that depends heavily on what else changed.
How noisy it is
This is the part that makes the card’s design make sense.
A study of daily resting heart rate in a large wearable population found two things worth knowing. Resting heart rate is seasonal: lowest in July, highest in January. And one person in five had at least one week that swung by 10 bpm or more.
Ten bpm is the same size as the difference the mortality meta-analysis attaches a 9% risk change to. A week of ordinary noise in one person covers the entire effect size of interest in a million people.
So a daily number is close to useless on its own, and a week-on-week comparison is only slightly better.
What Contrast does about it
A 28-day median. Not a mean, because one week of illness drags a mean and barely moves a median. Twenty-eight days is long enough to average out the weekly swing and short enough to notice a real shift.
Against the previous 28 days. The immediate comparison.
Against the same weeks last year, when a year of data exists. This is the interesting one. A February-to-March comparison is partly a seasonal trend; February-this-year against February-last-year is not.
A 2 bpm dead band. Changes under 2 bpm display as steady rather than as a direction. Given the underlying noise, a 1 bpm difference between two 28-day medians is not a finding.
Separately, days after a session are compared with other days once each side has at least five days in the last 90.
What it cannot tell you
The metric’s limits paragraph is blunt: fitness, sleep, stress, illness, alcohol, the season and medication all move resting heart rate. A change while using Contrast does not show that contrast therapy caused it.
And on the specific question people want answered, the app says a review found little evidence either way about whether cold exposure lowers resting heart rate. That is the honest state of it.
There is a related trap worth naming. Someone who starts a cold plunge habit in January and checks their resting heart rate in July will find it lower. So will someone who did nothing at all, because July is when it is lowest. The year-on-year comparison exists precisely to catch this.
What it is genuinely good for
Illness, a day or two early. A resting heart rate 5 to 8 bpm above your recent normal, sustained across two or three nights, is one of the more reliable early signals of an infection coming. It will not tell you what, and it is a good reason to skip the ice barrel.
Confirming a training effect. If you are training as well as plunging, a downward drift over months is more likely to be the training than the water, and the resting heart rate card is a reasonable way to watch it.
Sanity-checking heat strain. The heat strain metric subtracts your daily resting heart rate from your in-sauna heart rate, so it inherits any drift in resting heart rate. The app suggests reading the two together for that reason — if both are falling, the parsimonious explanation is general cardiovascular adaptation rather than heat-specific adaptation.
How to read it, in one line
A change under 2 bpm is nothing. A change of 2 to 5 bpm sustained over a month is worth noticing and probably has several causes. A change over 5 bpm that appeared suddenly and stayed is worth mentioning to a doctor, and that is the only sentence on this page that is advice.
Common questions
How does Contrast compare resting heart rate?
The median of your last 28 days against the 28 before, and against the same weeks last year when a year of data exists. Changes under 2 bpm are shown as steady.
Why compare against the same weeks last year?
Resting heart rate is seasonal, lowest in July and highest in January in one large study, so a February-to-March comparison carries a seasonal trend that a year-on-year comparison removes.
What is a normal resting heart rate?
For most adults, 60 to 100 bpm. Very active people can sit well below 60, and some are as low as 40.
Does cold exposure lower resting heart rate?
A review found little evidence either way. A change while using Contrast does not show that contrast therapy caused it. Fitness, sleep, stress, illness, the season and medication all move it.
Sources
- Zhang D, Shen X, Qi X. Resting heart rate and all-cause and cardiovascular mortality in the general population: a meta-analysis. CMAJ, 2016.
- Quer G, Gouda P, Galarnyk M, Topol EJ, Steinhubl SR. Inter- and intraindividual variability in daily resting heart rate. PLoS One, 2020.
- American Heart Association. All about heart rate (pulse).